Why banning the term ‘honour’ is misguided

banning-the-term-honour-feat

We understand the good intentions behind the attempt made by Nusrat Ghani MP in her Private Members Bill to ban the term ‘honour’ from official documents in respect of ‘honour’ killings or ‘honour-based violence. But the move is misguided.

The twin concepts of ‘honour’ and ‘shame’ remain central organising features of family life in many societies around the world. They underpin part of a powerful patriarchal canon by which the control of female sexuality is maintained. This is why violence perpetrated on women and girls in the name of ‘honour’ is increasingly recognised in international human rights laws and standards as a specific form of gender related violence. It is recognised in much the same way as other culturally specific forms of gender-based crimes like forced marriage and female genital mutilation. Human rights laws require states to understand the specific dynamics of, and risks associated with, such crimes: so that they can implement robust policies for their prosecution and prevention and provide sufficient support and access to justice for its victims.

Tinkering with terminology will not rectify the many failures of the British state to address ‘honour’ crimes adequately. What is essential is the provision of adequate legal and specialist services, and greater accountability from the police, prosecutorial and other state institutions. Currently, such institutions operate a culture of disbelief and indifference to gender-based violence. Banaz Mahmood, for instance, would not have been saved by a change in the terminology: but she might have been saved had the police learnt lessons from its systemic failures in other domestic related homicides.

Instead, we are witness to the decimation of the welfare state, the growing promotion of faith-based violence against women services and a proliferation of policies that seem to appease patriarchal and conservative religious ‘leaders’. Such leaders would, no doubt, support a ban on the use of the term ‘honour’. They deny their own complicity in honour-based crimes by viewing them as symptomatic of ‘malfunctioning cultures’ rather than the product of regressive religious values that are inseparable from culture. These developments have impacted disproportionately on black and minority women who are the most common victims of ‘honour’ crimes. These are the real issues that we should be making a noise about because paradoxically, despite progress made through feminist struggle, there are fewer and fewer options for exit and protection.

Perhaps the government could start by ratifying the Istanbul Convention and addressing the serious police failures and the issue of extra-territoriality raised in the specific case of Seeta Kaur. It could also re-think its relationships with faith-based leaderships and review the impact of the austerity measures and state policies that are proving to be major obstacles to achieving gender equality for all women.

Pragna Patel,
Director
Southall Black Sisters

If you agree, please support the statement by adding your name below

Supported by the following individuals and organisations:

Latest Signatures
61Peter TatchellMar 31, 2017
60Shamshad IqbalMar 29, 2017
59Julia MachinMar 24, 2017
58Miranda GrellMar 23, 2017
57Frances CarlisleMar 22, 2017
56Manjeet SinghMar 22, 2017
55Leo GaribMar 22, 2017
54Vicky MarshMar 22, 2017
53Annette AshleyMar 22, 2017
52Taranjit chanaMar 11, 2017
51Madeline PetrilloMar 11, 2017
50Kalwinder SandhuMar 11, 2017
49aisha Ali-KhanMar 11, 2017
48Musserat AshrafMar 11, 2017
47ruth appletonMar 11, 2017
46Romeela rehnaMar 11, 2017
45Bethany DaviesMar 11, 2017
44Shabanah FazalMar 11, 2017
43Hanan Mar 11, 2017
42Yasmin RehmanMar 11, 2017
41Emma RitchMar 11, 2017
40Julia BardMar 11, 2017
39Sarah Green & Rachel KrysMar 11, 2017
38Shakila Taranum MaanMar 11, 2017
37neeta patelMar 11, 2017
36Saba GillMar 11, 2017
35Sangitha KohsMar 11, 2017
34Samia MalikMar 11, 2017
33Anjum MoujMar 11, 2017
32Malika Klara ShahMar 11, 2017
31Leanne ConnorMar 11, 2017
30Lisa FitzpatrickMar 11, 2017
29Katarzyna AleksiejukMar 11, 2017
28Umme ImamMar 11, 2017
27Susan RobsonMar 11, 2017
26Bariza GhitiMar 11, 2017
25Cris McCurleyMar 11, 2017
24Sadiq BhanbhroMar 11, 2017
23Manija OmarMar 11, 2017
22Tania BronsteinMar 11, 2017
21Mili AcharyaMar 11, 2017
20M. Manwar AliMar 11, 2017
19Savita KurhadeMar 11, 2017
18Claudia BernardMar 11, 2017
17Shirley ShmmersMar 11, 2017
16Elena ClementeMar 11, 2017
15Gina khanMar 11, 2017
14Wouter VosMar 11, 2017
13Florence BinardMar 11, 2017
12Cecil WardMar 11, 2017
11Ruby SayedMar 11, 2017
10Alison TurnerMar 11, 2017
9Asma AshrafMar 11, 2017
8Andria MarshMar 11, 2017
7Mary KnightMar 11, 2017
6Amanda SimpsonMar 11, 2017
5Caoilfhionn Gallagher QCMar 11, 2017
4Rajiv Mar 11, 2017
3Keina YoshidaMar 11, 2017
2Sumaira shoukatMar 11, 2017
1julie kayaMar 11, 2017

Add your name to this statement

To add your name to this statement please fill out the short form below.

Please ensure you use a valid email address, it will need to be verified before your name can be added to this statement.

Banning the Term Honour Petition

[signature]

61 signatures

Share this with your friends: